Start with the Building, Not the Membrane
A roof that suits a warehouse may not suit an office with rooftop units or a building that will gain an addition. Before comparing products, list what the roof carries and who works on it: mechanical equipment, solar panels, skylights, foot traffic.
Hail matters here too. IBHS recommends hail guards on air conditioner condenser fins and other vulnerable rooftop components. If panels will sit on a low-slope roof, IBHS advises spacing the rows wide enough for maintenance crews to service damaged panels.
TPO and EPDM are single-ply sheets, and modified bitumen is a polymer-modified asphalt sheet. NRCA treats roofs at 3:12 (14 degrees) or less as low-slope membrane roofs, and each material has its own ASTM standard: D6878 for TPO, D4637 for EPDM, and D6162 and related standards for SBS modified bitumen.
Drainage Comes First
NRCA's test for adequate drainage is that no ponding water remains 48 hours after rain in drying conditions. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association adds that ponding can come from rain, melting snow or ice, or runoff from rooftop equipment. It can cause deck deflection, debris and plant growth, ice damage and leaks, and it recommends a slope of usually at least 1/4 inch per foot. It warns that failing to address ponding may shorten the effective life of the membrane system.
Where the deck is flat, tapered insulation can create slope. Crickets help around rooftop equipment, and HVAC condensate lines should connect to proper drains.
Colorado Springs adds a winter wrinkle. National Weather Service normals list a January average high of 45.0 degrees and low of 18.5, with 32.5 inches of snow a year. Snow that melts by day and refreezes at night is what blocks drains. IBHS advises clearing drainage of debris before melt, and considering snow removal when big temperature swings are forecast.
Look at the Existing Roof Assembly
A roof is a membrane, insulation and deck working together. NRCA notes that fire classifications apply to complete tested assemblies, not membranes alone. It also advocates cover boards, which are recognized for added impact and puncture resistance.
Ask what the inspection found under the surface, and whether the existing assembly can stay or must come off. For existing buildings, IBHS recommends a structural engineer verify snow load capacity.
Hail, Altitude and Sun
In hail-prone areas, IBHS recommends low-slope roof covers that meet FM 4470 Class 1-SH or UL 2218 Class 4. It also says impact-resistant metal roofs are likely to survive hail without functional damage but can show permanent dents. The June 2018 storm that dropped 2.5-inch hail at Fort Carson and 3.0-inch hail in Fountain, per the National Weather Service, shows the stakes. See our guide to hail damage on Colorado Springs roofs.
The National Weather Service's Colorado Springs airport station sits at about 6,180 feet (1,885 meters). UV rises with altitude: the EPA's UV model uses about 6 percent per kilometer, and the World Health Organization cites roughly 10 percent per 1,000 meters. Ask how each membrane and its coating handle sun.
Where the Four Systems Fit
JR&CO works with TPO, EPDM, modified bitumen and metal. What the sources support:
- TPO and EPDM: single-ply membranes. Ask for the manufacturer's tested assembly ratings.
- Modified bitumen: some systems are applied with a torch. IBHS calls improper torch work a fire hazard and recommends a written hot work program.
- Metal: IBHS notes standing-seam and snap-lock systems can go on slopes as low as 2 percent under some code editions.
Which fits your building comes down to the drainage, assembly and hail points above, confirmed on site.
What a Maintenance and Inspection Plan Covers
NRCA recommends inspecting roofs at least twice a year, preferably spring and fall, and after severe weather such as hailstorms. A plan should include:
- A visual inspection of the roof and adjacent surfaces, noting any deterioration.
- Clearing debris, especially around drains, valleys and gutters.
- Checking that drains are unobstructed and no water ponds.
- After heavy winter events, an IBHS-recommended look at the deck and framing from below for sagging, moisture or rust.
- Prompt repairs by an experienced roofer.
NRCA says most warranties require proper maintenance, and that a program allows planned budgeting. JR&CO offers roof maintenance programs and inspections with photo documentation, so you keep a dated record.
What to Ask a Contractor
IBHS's hiring checklist for commercial roofs suggests asking for:
- A well-established, licensed and bonded company with a permanent address.
- References from commercial buildings in your area.
- Current certificates of insurance for liability and workers' compensation.
- Manufacturer specifications and test approvals for the proposed system.
- Manufacturer and installation warranties, including exclusions.
- A written safety plan covering OSHA fall protection, plus a weather plan.
- A check for complaints with the Better Business Bureau.
- Several bids, without choosing on the lowest price alone.
IBHS also notes some systems need certain temperatures to install, so ask about scheduling. JR&CO's local project experience includes the U.S. Air Force Academy Cadet Chapel enclosure roof and an aerospace facility in Colorado Springs.
Plan Your Roof
For a free estimate, use the estimate form or see our commercial and industrial roofing services. JR&CO is a veteran-owned, family-operated contractor, established in 1986, at 8045 Iron Tower Ct., Colorado Springs, CO 80939, (719) 244-9636. If your building is mid-decision, see roof repair versus replacement in Colorado Springs.
Sources
- IBHS, Commercial Roofs Best Practices Guide
- IBHS, Roof 101
- NRCA, "Guidelines for designing low-slope membrane roof systems" (2015)
- NRCA, "Most frequently asked technical questions" (2013)
- NRCA, "Maintaining residential roof systems" (2013)
- Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association, Effects of Ponding Water (2024)
- NWS Pueblo, Colorado Springs normals and extremes
- NWS API, Colorado Springs Municipal Airport station (KCOS)
- NWS Pueblo, Hail Storm in El Paso County (June 13, 2018)
- EPA, Learn About the UV Index
- WHO, Ultraviolet (UV) radiation Q&A
