Let the Inspection Decide
Age alone does not settle repair versus replacement. What settles it is how much of the roof is affected, what caused the damage, and what you plan to do with the building. A documented inspection gives you those answers before you spend money.
Signs a Repair Is Enough
- A few loose or missing pieces. NRCA says dislodged or missing shingle tabs should be repaired to keep the roof weathertight. For tile, slate, wood shingles and shakes, and metal shingles, cracked, broken or missing pieces should be repaired or replaced.
- Small scope. A repair limited to a small area is a smaller job. The Pikes Peak Regional Building Department (PPRBD) requires a permit for repair or replacement work over 100 square feet.
NRCA advises homeowners to hire an experienced roofing contractor for repairs rather than attempting them without the experience and equipment.
Signs Replacement Is Worth Pricing
- Spreading deterioration. NRCA calls shingle curling or splitting evidence of deterioration. When it appears across slopes, patching can turn into a cycle.
- Repeat leaks. A leak that returns after repair, or shows up in new places, points past a single fault.
- Widespread storm damage. The Colorado Division of Insurance (DOI) notes that after a severe storm some owners find they need a new roof.
- Plans for the building. Selling, adding rooftop equipment or installing solar all favor deciding on the whole roof now.
Replacement pricing is not a decision to replace. It lets you compare the two options with real numbers.
How Age, Leaks, Storms and Plans Change the Answer
Age
Ask for the roof's age and covering type. NRCA cautions that long warranties often limit your remedies and that most require proper maintenance, so read the terms before leaning on one. Whichever way you go, NRCA recommends inspecting a roof at least twice a year, preferably spring and fall, and after severe weather such as a hailstorm. A maintenance record also helps you plan future roof spending.
Repeat Leaks
Ask what each earlier repair fixed and whether the leak came back in the same spot or a new one. A roof that leaks in several places is telling you something a patch will not fix.
Storm Damage
The DOI says work for damage that was not part of the storm will not be covered. Coverage depends on your policy and your insurer's inspection. After hail or wind, JR&CO documents the damage and works with your insurance company. If the roof must be replaced, the DOI's commissioner suggests asking your insurer about premium discounts or future deductible savings for hail-resistant material. For storm steps, read hail damage on Colorado Springs roofs.
Plans for the Building
PPRBD requires a detach-and-reset solar permit, pulled by a licensed contractor, before solar arrays come off the structure. PPRBD also bars asphalt shingles on a pitch below 2:12, so a low-slope section may need a different system. See commercial roofing in Colorado Springs for flat-roof options.
What Colorado Springs Weather Adds
Winter in Colorado Springs swings across freezing: National Weather Service normals show a January average high of 45.0 degrees and low of 18.5, with 32.5 inches of snow a year. IBHS reports that shingle sealant activates in the sun's heat, that manufacturers recommend 70 to 80 degrees for sealing, and that shingles may not seal properly below 40 degrees. Ask when and how a cold-season job would be done.
Hail is the other local factor. On June 13, 2018, the National Weather Service reported 2.5-inch hail at Fort Carson and 3.0-inch hail in Fountain. Roofs that have been through a storm like that deserve a documented inspection even when they look fine from the street.
The World Health Organization estimates UV levels rise about 10 percent for every 1,000 meters of altitude. The National Weather Service's Colorado Springs airport station sits at about 6,180 feet (1,885 meters).
What an Inspection Should Hand You
- Dated photos of each problem area and the roof overall.
- Where the damage is, how much of the roof it covers, and the likely cause.
- A repair option and a replacement option, each with a clear scope.
- Which findings are storm damage and which are wear.
- The material rating of anything proposed. IBHS says UL 2218 Class 4 means passing impact tests with a 2-inch steel ball, and those tests do not account for aging.
JR&CO estimates are free, and its inspections include photo documentation.
Permit and Code Rules in Colorado Springs
PPRBD's reroofing guidelines (revision dated March 2024) summarize these points, and tell you to check the currently adopted codes:
- Any repair or replacement over 100 square feet needs a permit, and contracting reroofs over that size requires a license unless you own the home and it is your primary residence.
- New asphalt roofing may not go on until all existing layers are removed from a home.
- Shingle roofs need drip edge at eaves and rakes.
- Properties above 7,000 feet need an ice barrier. The permit receipt lists the property's elevation.
- Stocking materials before the permit is issued can bring a triple permit fee and a stop work order.
Get a Free Estimate
For a free estimate, use the estimate form or see our roof repair and service options. JR&CO is a veteran-owned, family-operated roofer established in 1986, at 8045 Iron Tower Ct., Colorado Springs, CO 80939, (719) 244-9636.
Sources
- NRCA, "Maintaining residential roof systems" (2013)
- PPRBD, Reroofing Guidelines, revision 03/05/2024 (archived copy)
- Colorado Division of Insurance, hailstorm consumer advisory (May 31, 2024)
- NWS Pueblo, Colorado Springs normals and extremes
- NWS Pueblo, Hail Storm in El Paso County (June 13, 2018)
- NWS API, Colorado Springs Municipal Airport station (KCOS)
- IBHS, Roof 101
- WHO, Ultraviolet (UV) radiation Q&A
